Choosing the right window company is one of the most important decisions you'll make for your home. With so many brands claiming to be "the best," it's hard to know who to trust. As professional window installers who work with multiple manufacturers, we're sharing our honest assessmentof the top window companies in 2024.
Our Evaluation Criteria
We've evaluated each company based on: product quality, warranty coverage, energy efficiency, Arizona climate suitability, value for money, and dealer/service support in the Phoenix area.
Quick Comparison Table
| Company | Rating | Price | Warranty | Best For |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Pella | 4.8 | $$$-$$$$ | Limited Lifetime | Innovation & Customization |
| Milgard | 4.7 | $$-$$$ | Full Lifetime (Transferable) | Value & Warranty |
| Andersen | 4.5 | $$$-$$$$ | Limited Lifetime | Brand Recognition |
| Marvin | 4.6 | $$$$ | Limited Lifetime | Luxury & Custom Homes |
| Simonton | 4.2 | $-$$ | Limited Lifetime | Budget-Conscious Buyers |
Detailed Company Reviews
Pella
Pros
- Extensive customization options
- Industry-leading innovation
- Excellent fiberglass options (Impervia)
- Between-the-glass blinds available
- Smart home integration
Cons
- Higher price point
- Warranty not fully transferable
🌵 Arizona Note:
Impervia fiberglass excels in extreme heat. Highly recommended for Phoenix.
Milgard
Pros
- Best warranty in the industry
- Fully transferable lifetime warranty
- Excellent value for quality
- West Coast manufacturing (faster delivery)
- Strong dealer network in Arizona
Cons
- Fewer customization options than Pella
- No between-the-glass blinds
🌵 Arizona Note:
Full Lifetime Warranty transfers to new owners - excellent for resale value.
Andersen
Pros
- Longest company history
- Wide product range
- Available at big box stores
- Good wood window options
Cons
- Quality varies by product line
- Less dealer support in Arizona
- Some products not ideal for extreme heat
🌵 Arizona Note:
Quality varies. Stick with their higher-end lines for Arizona climate.
Marvin
Pros
- Premium quality craftsmanship
- Excellent for custom architectural projects
- Beautiful wood options
- Made-to-order flexibility
Cons
- Highest price point
- Long lead times
- Limited local dealer support
🌵 Arizona Note:
Best for luxury custom homes. Overkill for typical residential projects.
Simonton
Pros
- Affordable pricing
- Good entry-level options
- Available through contractors
Cons
- Less durable in extreme climates
- Fewer style options
- Vinyl may struggle in Arizona heat
🌵 Arizona Note:
Be cautious - standard vinyl can warp in Arizona summer temperatures.
Our Recommendations for Arizona Homeowners
For Maximum Value
Milgard offers the best combination of quality, price, and warranty. Their Full Lifetime Warranty is unmatched in the industry.
Explore Milgard →For Extreme Heat Performance
Pella Impervia fiberglass handles Arizona's brutal summers better than any other material. Worth the investment.
Explore Pella Impervia →For Luxury Custom Homes
Pella Lifestyle or Marvin for homes where aesthetics and customization are top priorities.
Explore Pella Lifestyle →Budget-Friendly Option
Pella 250 Series vinyl offers excellent value with quality that can handle Arizona conditions.
Explore Pella 250 Series →The Bottom Line
For most Arizona homeowners, we recommend either Pella or Milgard. Both brands offer excellent quality, strong warranties, and products specifically suited for our extreme desert climate. The choice between them often comes down to whether you prioritize customization (Pella) or warranty coverage (Milgard).
Avoid budget brands that use standard vinyl not rated for extreme heat - they may save money upfront but can warp and fail within a few years in Phoenix's 110°F summers.